The Nintendo Switch’s default Joy-Con controllers, while offering wireless convenience and detachable functionality, fall short in terms of comfort, especially during extended gaming sessions or for users with larger hands. While Nintendo has made efforts to address the notorious Joy-Con drift issue, some concerns remain. This necessitates exploring alternative controllers that prioritize both comfort and reliability, along with unique features tailored to individual playstyles. This guide focuses on wireless controllers, excluding wired options due to their limited advantages and basic functionality. It’s important to note that third-party controllers often lack certain features found in Nintendo’s official offerings, such as HD rumble, motion controls, NFC reader for Amiibo, and the ability to remotely power on the console.
For docked Switch gameplay, the official Nintendo Switch Pro Controller stands out as the optimal choice. It boasts a traditional gamepad design, encompassing all the essential features, except a 3.5mm headphone jack. Its build quality and comfort are unmatched among comparable controllers. Moreover, it offers HD rumble, motion controls, Amiibo support, and the unique ability to power on the Switch remotely. The long battery life, estimated at 40 hours, adds to its appeal. While the lack of programmable buttons or a headphone jack is a minor drawback, the overall package makes it the best option for docked play.
For handheld mode, the Hori Split Pad Pro shines as a superior alternative to the Joy-Cons. Designed as two separate pieces that slide onto the Switch console, it offers larger, more accessible buttons, triggers, and analog sticks, enhancing comfort and grip. This makes it ideal for longer play sessions and fast-paced gameplay. However, its lack of batteries and sensors means it’s exclusively for handheld use, unless paired with the Split Pad Pro Attachment, which converts it into a wired controller. While the attachment adds a headphone jack, its cost exceeding that of a Pro Controller makes the latter a more sensible investment in most cases.
Gamers who prefer the Xbox controller layout can opt for the GuliKit KingKong 3 Pro and Max. These controllers offer an Xbox-style design with high-quality build and features rivaling the Switch Pro Controller. They boast drift-free Hall effect sticks and triggers, customizable RGB lighting, detachable back buttons, and compatibility with Switch, PC, macOS, SteamOS, and mobile devices. The KingKong 3 Max adds physical trigger stops and more back buttons, offering further customization options. Both controllers feature GuliKit’s enhanced vibration motors with multiple intensity levels and modes, including HD rumble. While the lack of a dedicated software app for easier management is a minor drawback, their versatility and value make them compelling choices.
The 8BitDo Ultimate Bluetooth Controller presents a strong alternative to the Switch Pro Controller, offering similar form factor and compatibility with Switch, PC, and Steam Deck. While its haptics aren’t as refined as Nintendo’s, and it lacks Amiibo support, it compensates with customizable back paddles, motion controls, and a charging dock that stores the 2.4GHz dongle. The ability to wake a docked Switch with a shake adds a unique touch. Its 22-hour battery life, while shorter than the Pro Controller’s, is still commendable. The included Ultimate Software allows customization of button mapping, macros, vibration intensity, and stick/trigger sensitivity. The multiple customizable profiles and turbo button further enhance its versatility.
For those accustomed to the PlayStation controller layout, the 8BitDo Pro 2 provides a compelling alternative. Resembling a DualShock controller, it offers a comfortable grip, a superior D-pad compared to the Switch Pro Controller, and two underside paddle buttons. It features rumble support (albeit not HD rumble), motion control, and customizable button mapping, stick/trigger sensitivity through 8BitDo’s Ultimate software. The ability to save and switch between three control profiles adds to its appeal. Its compatibility with various devices, including Switch, PC, Steam Deck, mobile, and Raspberry Pi, coupled with its affordable price, makes it an attractive option.
Finally, the 8BitDo Wireless Bluetooth USB Adapter 2 provides a cost-effective solution for using existing controllers with the Switch. This adapter allows wireless pairing of various PlayStation, Xbox, and Nintendo controllers with the Switch dock. It supports a wide range of controllers, from current-gen models to older consoles like the Wii and PlayStation 3. Notably, it offers good rumble and motion control performance with compatible controllers, and even allows customization through 8BitDo’s software. While some setup is required and on-screen prompts might not match controller layouts, its affordability and versatility make it a valuable accessory.
