American Primeval, Netflix’s breakout hit of 2025, captivated audiences and reigned supreme in the streaming charts, even dethroning the highly anticipated Squid Games season 2. Its success naturally sparked discussions about a potential continuation, but the show’s classification as a miniseries presented a unique challenge. Miniseries are typically designed as self-contained narratives, and while some have successfully transitioned into multi-season formats, such as The White Lotus and Shogun, others remain singular stories. American Primeval appears to be navigating this dilemma by exploring a compromise: a spin-off rather than a direct sequel.
The concept of a spin-off allows the American Primeval universe to expand while respecting the original miniseries’ self-contained narrative. This approach garnered further traction when creator and director Peter Berg addressed the possibility of exploring the backstory of Isaac, a compelling character portrayed by Taylor Kitsch. In an interview, Berg acknowledged ongoing discussions about a prequel series centered around Isaac, hinting that this would be the preferred route should the project move forward. This statement not only confirmed active consideration of a continuation but also revealed the specific direction such a continuation would take.
While the prospect of an Isaac-centric prequel appeared promising, the possibility of a traditional season 2 with the original cast faced significant hurdles. Berg highlighted the production challenges encountered due to the industry strike, which caused a five-month hiatus. During this period, Preston, the young actor portraying Devin, underwent significant physical changes due to puberty, making it difficult to seamlessly resume filming with the same cast and maintain continuity. These logistical and narrative complications effectively ruled out a direct second season, further solidifying the prequel spin-off as the most viable option.
The potential prequel series, focusing on Isaac’s past, offers a rich narrative landscape for exploration. Given the character’s complexity and Kitsch’s compelling performance, delving into Isaac’s origins promises a captivating story that can stand on its own while enriching the existing American Primeval universe. It would allow the creators to explore the events and experiences that shaped Isaac into the man he becomes in the miniseries, providing a deeper understanding of his motivations and adding layers of depth to the overarching narrative.
The likelihood of the prequel materializing appears high, considering Berg’s enthusiasm for the idea and the show’s exceptional performance. The success of American Primeval provides a strong foundation for a spin-off, indicating a substantial audience eager to explore more of this world. Furthermore, Berg’s clear preference for the prequel concept, coupled with the logistical challenges of a direct sequel, strongly suggests that the spin-off is the most probable path forward. While the timeline remains uncertain, the combination of a compelling premise, enthusiastic creator, and successful original series makes the eventual arrival of an American Primeval prequel seem highly plausible.
While official confirmation may still be some time away, the signs point towards a continuation of the American Primeval story, albeit through a different lens. The prequel approach allows for creative expansion within the established universe while circumventing the limitations imposed by the miniseries format and production challenges. This strategy provides a promising avenue for revisiting the world of American Primeval, offering audiences a fresh perspective and deeper exploration of its captivating characters and intriguing premise. The prequel route offers both creative freedom and narrative continuity, promising a compelling new chapter in the American Primeval saga.
