The recent revival of Hollywood Squares, helmed by CBS Mornings and NFL Today host Nate Burleson, breathes new life into the classic game show, delivering fast-paced fun and comedic energy that leaves viewers wanting more. The decision to air back-to-back episodes within an hour-long slot proves a winning formula, maximizing the entertainment impact and capitalizing on the quick-witted exchanges between celebrity panelists. While the modernized set and theme song signal a fresh approach, the core essence of the show remains, promising a nostalgic yet contemporary viewing experience.
However, the choice of Drew Barrymore as the center square, a position historically occupied by comedic giants like Paul Lynde and Joan Rivers, presents a significant point of contention. While Barrymore’s existing relationship with CBS as a talk show host and executive producer explains her placement, her lack of comedic expertise makes her a questionable fit for this pivotal role. The center square demands sharp wit, improvisational skills, and the ability to deliver consistently funny quips – qualities that seasoned comedians possess in abundance. Barrymore’s presence, while undoubtedly adding star power, fails to capture the comedic spark that defined previous iterations of the show.
Despite this central casting misstep, the overall ensemble of celebrities delivers a mixed bag of comedic hits and misses, leaving the audience to determine their personal favorites. The first two episodes feature a diverse lineup, including established comedians like Tiffany Haddish, Drew Carey, Whitney Cummings, and Jeff Ross, alongside actors and personalities like Julie Bowen, Tyra Banks, Pete Holmes, Bobby Moynihan, Thomas Lennon, Debi Mazar, Chelsea Peretti, JB Smoove, Tichina Arnold, Nicole Byer, and even Triumph the Insult Comic Dog. This eclectic mix generates an unpredictable and often hilarious dynamic, contributing to the show’s overall entertainment value.
The sheer energy and exuberance displayed by the celebrity panel inject a frenetic pace into the gameplay. Their reactions, often bordering on hysterical, amplify the comedic moments, creating a contagious atmosphere of laughter. While this amplified energy may not resonate with every viewer, it undeniably contributes to the lighthearted and entertaining nature of the show. This over-the-top enthusiasm seems almost a prerequisite for a format like Hollywood Squares, emphasizing the fun and playful spirit of the game.
The show’s success lies in its ability to blend nostalgia with contemporary elements. While the core format remains true to the original Hollywood Squares, the modernized set, updated theme song, and current roster of celebrities inject a fresh perspective. This blend appeals to both long-time fans of the show and newer audiences, creating a broad appeal. Burleson’s hosting style further enhances this balance, providing a smooth and engaging presence that connects the different elements of the show.
Beyond the entertainment value, the revival of Hollywood Squares also demonstrates a respectful nod to the show’s legacy. The producers’ decision to acknowledge legendary former host Peter Marshall at the beginning of the first episode demonstrates an appreciation for the show’s history. This gesture reinforces the connection between the past and present iterations of Hollywood Squares, acknowledging the contributions of those who shaped the show into the iconic format it is today. While no one can truly replace the iconic Paul Lynde, the new Hollywood Squares offers a fresh take on a beloved classic, promising continued entertainment for new generations of viewers. The show’s fast-paced format, comedic interplay, and contemporary updates ensure its relevance in today’s television landscape, demonstrating that the concept of Hollywood Squares remains timeless and entertaining.
